I’ve always liked the line from Good Will Hunting regarding not underestimating where a novel questioning of the status quo may come from:
Professor Lambeau:
“In 1905 there were hundreds of professors renowned for their study of the universe, but it was a 26 year old Swiss patent clerk, doing physics in his spare time who changed the world. Can you imagine if Einstein would have given that up just to get drunk with his buddies?”

By the way, it wasn’t a “Swiss patent clerk”, it was the German-born Einstein working in Switzerland. But I digress…
What’s unique in the paleo/evolutionary living community is that there are paleo medical professionals who admit what they previously didn’t know and acknowledge that they learned it from people outside of a so-called prerequisite field. There are also many paleo health and fitness professionals rendering nutrition and weight training “treatments” that are doing more for people than any mainstream M.D. pushing a low-fat concoction of horror. In turn, there are a lot of low-fat, low-intensity, heavy on the pasta and cardio type of trainers making a lot of money in appearance fees but whose actual advice isn’t worth a penny compared to a low-carb (normal carb!) doctor’s medical appointment.
In the end, it’s the combination like that of Professor Arthur De Vany, Mark Sisson & Robb Wolf with Drs. Eades, McGuff and Davis (and countless others) that allows for the paleo remnant to see that the clinical and the research minded evidence is out there, understood, explained and offered by the Doc to his patients, by the trainer to his trainee, and by the wise professor to a gathering crowd seeking epistemology.
Mainstream Medicine would like you to ignore evolutionary biology, evolutionary psychology and all forms of evolutionary medicine and accept on faith and faith alone the government approved food pyramid, HFCS, and the false correlation of cholesterol & heart disease. Mainstream Medicine hoists up a cheap sheepskin (educational/medical degree) onto a vanquished and crumbling low-fat/high-carb rampart as if that sheepskin allows for someone to deny gravity (or the existence of insulin). And in the same breath, they reject all of humanity’s accumulated medical knowledge from the dawn of time until Ancel Keys did his Seven Countries Study with cooked books. Essentially, such skewed statistics became gospel, and those that questioned “the modern low-fat medicine men” were called witch doctors.
However, the strength of the evolutionary living community is completely opposite. There are no sacred texts. The paleo clinicians (the trainers, the crossfitters, the lifters, the reformed carb-addicts) and the paleo doctors are learning with each other. One group feeding data to the other group and circling back again.
The challenge before you is to learn what all of these different voices are saying. If you’re a doctor, resist pride and understand that the Ancel Keys textbooks you have studied are no more than a bucket of leaches. You’re still required to pay those medical student loans that made you take those Ancel-inspired courses, however, that fact shouldn’t stand in your way. On the other hand, if you’re a layman, whether a bricklayer, a bodybuilder or a lawyer, resist the temptation of submitting to the “approved” health advice meme. You were never given the full explanation of all of what they said before, so don’t just repeat the words of the medical professionals you see on CNN or on Oprah and accept it as the gospel truth.




This requires you not to just regurgitate the latest epidemiological statistic paid for by the obligatory interest group, but to actually dig in a bit on the endocrinological basis of the paleo diet. Read up on the evolutionary basis as to why our fast and slow twitch muscles do that they do. Why lifting heavy things beats a spin class. Why a 30 minute walk or jog doesn’t mean you’ve ”earned” your breakfast of a yogurt, bagel and orange juice. Don’t take it all at face value. Cross reference. Google it.
Read The Paleo Diet.
Read Good Calories, Bad Calories.
Read Primal Blueprint.
Read The Protein Power Plan.
Read Body By Science.
Read articles from Nutrition and Metabolism (with a dictionary handy expecting to only understand 30% at first).
Read the dozens of other paleo sites out there of people (whether they have a medical degree or not) performing n=1 methodology (h/t health epistemocrat).
If you can’t explain it in layman’s terms to someone else, you’re not there yet. As a layman or doctor if you can’t politely discuss this with low-fat doctors without posing questions leaving them speechless, you’re not there yet. I don’t have a cabinet to store this all in, instead it’s stored in the evolutionary living community members I listen to, the things I read, the decisions I make, it’s in the food I eat, it’s in the rest while I sleep, and it’s in the words I offer up to others for their sake in return.
There’s a Native American phrase when praising someone that says,”He/she has strong medicine.” But in the English vernacular that doesn’t mean that the person necessarily had the best pharmacy in the tribe (e.g., really knew about herbs), it could have meant a whole host of things. The person offered good words at a pow-wow or meeting, the person offered good prayers or perhaps provided good spiritual guidance. Maybe, the person was indeed the best at presiding over a religious service. Or, it could actually mean that his/her ability to look for and find herbs for medicinal purposes was second to none.

A couple of weeks ago I made a list of the great evolutionary living sites out there. I made a mistake by putting the group in cardinal order. What I should have done was to describe these sites as members of a “support group” or even a paleo council. So, those that were on my recent list should not be seen as being numbered from 1 to 10, it should be seen rather as a group sitting in a circle, with no distinction of rank or title. They were mentioned because I find them to provide rather good paleo medicine, in the above mentioned sense. Mark Sisson may be the only “medicine” I take on a given day, other times it’s from many others not even on that list.
Learn how to make “medicine” for yourself. This means actually understanding why and what your doctor is prescribing for you. This may indeed require prescription pills under the supervision of a doctor or perhaps even surgery at points in your life. In no way am I implying that modern medical knowledge shouldn’t be considered, or that you should avoid going to the hospital when you have a broken leg! But remember, just because an Ancel Keys indoctrinated doctor can write a prescription on a pad of paper doesn’t mean that he’s giving good medicine. Thankfully, we have doctors amongst us in this online paleo world that are humble and wise enough to admit to you that they learned about good paleo medicine after years of handing out bad medicine. ![]()















